We often hear how the media on the East and West Coast is creating a bias that forgets about sports in the middle of America. Well if baseball teams had a problem with this, they certainly aren’t showing it, as the NL and AL Central divisions are exhibiting some of the worst play in the league and are truly wide-open.
The NL Central has been a division controlled by the Cardinals over the past decade. With the Cincinnati Reds surprising most by winning the division in 2010, and with the Brewers adding key pieces to the roster, much was expected from the Top 3 teams in this division. However, the NL Central has been filled with a plethora of injuries, miscues, and under-performing.
First, we will quickly cast-off the Houston Astros, as most fans cannot name 5 players (Hunter Pence, Carlos Lee.¤.¤.???). To put it simply, the Astros are a joke. Then you take the Cubs, and we all know about the Cubs. It’s been a long time since they won a World Series, and they continue to be hampered by bad contracts like Alfonso Soriano and Kosuke Fukudome. Without a plan as to where they are going, the Cubs will continue to be the lovable losers for a time to come.
Now, onto the supposed top 3.
The Milwaukee Brewers made a few splashes in the off-season, acquiring pitchers Shaun Marcum and former Cy Young award winner Zack Greinke, via trades. The two combined are 15-6, but Greinke’s ERA of 5.06 isn’t fooling anybody. Recently the team traded for Mets closer Francisco Rodriguez and will help close games for Milwaukee with John Axford. Despite all this, an MVP-caliber season from Prince Fielder, and another All-Star season from Ryan Braun, the Brewers are only 5 games over .500 and are battling a top the division.
Who are they battling with? Not last year’s division-champion Cincinnati Reds, who sit at 47-50 and have even resorted to using Dontrelle Willis (who knew he was still around?) as a starter this year. Joey Votto and Jay Bruce have provided the club with solid offensive production, but the pitching staff has been more then iffy. Volquez, Wood and Arroyo all have ERA’s over 5 and veteran closer Francisco Cordero has shown signs of age. The Reds have the talent to contend, but are cruising well below expectations in 2011.
The Cardinals have the best player in baseball, Albert Pujols, and despite star pitcher Adam Wainwright not pitching this season, and many other injuries occurring during the season, including Pujols, the Cardinals are still fighting for the division lead. Pitching Coach Dave Duncan and manager Tony LaRussa are two of the best coaches in the game and will always have this team contending.
Still, the most telling reason for why this division stinks is that the Pittsburgh Pirates are in first place. Yes, the same Pirates who haven’t had a winning season since 1992. Now you can sit there and try to tell me that Andrew McCutchen is a great player, and that the Pirates have built this team over the years, but the truth is the Pirates still really aren’t that good. Their pitching staff is incredibly mediocre, with names like Kevin Correia spotlighting the staff. Despite some talent, the Pirates have no business being in a division race this late in the season, and the NL Central is just awful. Sure the Pirates are a feel-good story, but they should not be leading a division in the second half of the season. Especially a division of 6 teams!

Now on to the AL Central, which has is seemingly going to be won by default by the Detroit Tigers.
The Tigers have one of the best pitchers in the AL in Justin Verlander, and the offense is filled with many talented veteran bats including Miguel Cabrera, Victor Martinez, and Magglio Ordonez. Yet despite all this, the team finds themselves at 51-45. This team is certainly the favorite to win the division, but some more consistency is going to be needed.
The Royals, well they suck.
The Twins have somehow managed to battle in the division every year, despite a less-than-decent pitching rotation and 2 all-star bats. This year, the injuries have just caught up to them, with key injuries to Mauer and Morneau, not even the great Ron Gardenhire can pull this one out.
The White Sox are filled with veterans, and certainly should be at least a .500 team, if not contending for the division. But the team is playing sloppy and careless ball and manager Ozzie Guillen might be in his last season as skipper of the White Sox. I wouldn’t count this team out, but they need to get going, especially Adam Dunn.

And now to the Indians, a team similar to the Pittsburgh Pirates because no one saw this one coming. They are currently tied atop the division with the Tigers and it’s hard to figure out how. Grady Sizemore has been injured and bad, their closer is journeyman Chris Perez, and their top starter is Fausto Carmona. The only answer to how this is possible is that the division is terrible. The Indians jumped out to an incredibly fast start, having the best record in baseball for quite sometime. Since then reality has set in, and the team has come back to Earth. Still, they find themselves in contention, and with a few deadline deals, they could steal this division. Heck, why not?
Sure the MLB will promote these division races as exciting and great baseball, but the truth is, both of these divisions stink. Two of these teams will make the playoffs, but I don’t expect them to last much longer then that. They are all far from the level of the Yankees, Red Sox, Rangers, Phillies, Giants, and Braves and I expect to see the winner of the two Central divisions eliminated in the first round of the playoffs. Sorry to Middle America, but your baseball is terrible.